With the much-hyped first user-generated debate officially in the books, and with generally positive reviews, we will take a look at which candidate fared best in the YouTube/CNN democratic presidential forum.
Winners
For CNN's political analyst Debate Scorecard it was a clean sweep for Hillary Clinton. Bill Press thought she was "forceful" with a "good sense of humor," while GOP strategist Leslie Sanchez thought the New York senator "sound(ed) much less like an automaton than usual." Although they didn't choose him as the winner, all three thought Joe Biden was the most knowledgeable. "You could hear his deep knowledge and experience," said Bill Schneider.
Time's Joe Klein also went with Clinton, saying "(her) pointing out that the groundwork (for talking to 'foreign leaders') had to be done was, dare I say it, judicious and presidential...and made Obama look, well, inexperienced."
Chris Cillizza of The Fix was more generous, awarding "wins" to Clinton, John Edwards, Bill Richardson and the Format. "Watching the pre-debate coverage on CNN, they were setting themselves up for either a home run or a swinging strikeout. Well, in this viewer's mind, they belted it out of the park," said Cillizza.
Steven Stark of The Tote Board thought the candidates that did best "were those who came off as real and not overtly political." And those, according to Stark, were Barack Obama, Edwards and Biden, noting the Delaware senator did "especially (well) in the second half when he finally managed not to sound so angry."
The Politico's Roger Simon thought Edwards edged out Clinton, writing "John Edwards has found a theme: He is angry and he is on your side. He is bold and he will use his boldness for you."
Mark Halperin, of Time, gave Obama the nod with an "A-," saying "When he was good, he was very, very good. When he wasn't, he was dangerously close to ordinary."
Meanwhile, Survey USA polled 717 debate watchers and they declared Clinton the winner with 39%. Obama was second with 15% and Biden a close third with 14%.
CNN's online poll also went to Clinton with 48% picking the former first lady over Obama and Biden.
Losers
Again a clean sweep from CNN and, again, it wasn't good for Richardson, who has struggled in previous debates. Schneider thought the New Mexico governor "sometimes seemed a little shaky, but he got better as the debate went on."
Klein also wasn't too keen on Richardson's performance but only had "Enough already" to say about Dennis Kucinich and Mike Gravel.
Cillizza, who picked Richardson as a "winner," thought Gravel and Al Gore were the night's losers, saying of the former Vice President, "Gore always benefits if he seems like a missing presence in the debate hall. He wasn't last night."
Gravel was also awarded last place by Simon, but the Politico analyst also admitted "he is growing on us."
Halperin ranked Gravel a "D" but also wasn't too impressed with Richardson, saying he "didn't get to talk for the first 20 minutes — and it was downhill from there."
Gravel was the choice of the people as a third of those polled by Survey USA named the former Alaska senator as the night's loser.
CNN's online poll, though, rated Richardson as giving the most disappointing performance.